5 Places for The Best Bagels in Chicago

Tilly Bagel Shop for the Best Bagels in Chicago

Chicagoans are incredibly appreciative of Hannah Tillet, who is the driving force behind this recently launched takeout and delivery business. Tillet has worked as a pastry chef in the past and has experience working at prominent eateries like BOKA and Girl & The Goat. She has since turned her attention to refining the bagel. You can find Chicago’s best bagels over here. Her dough is made in small batches and is naturally leavened with a sourdough starter to guarantee the highest level of freshness. These suckers are in high demand, so place an online order in advance.

Steingold’s of Chicago

For Chicago’s best bagels, Steingold is the right place to be. Steingold’s is a Jewish deli at its core, even while it embraces the world while maintaining a strong connection to the traditional delis of New York City’s Lower East Side. This modern Jewish deli in the middle of Chicago promises “New York bagels, the Chicago way,” a tiny piece of New York’s Lower East Side. Daily baked products are produced there, and while they adhere to a tried-and-true recipe, they also occasionally shake it up. Like dipping a fast food fry into a chocolate milkshake, their current bagel of the month is flavoured like a French fry and spread with chocolate malt cream cheese.  Pastrami is chopped thick to order, lox is house-cured, and dough for bagels is fermented overnight before being boiled and baked every day. You will probably find the Best Bagels in Chicago at Steingol’s.

The deli avant-garde, which includes traditional menu items like pastrami, matzoh ball soup, and bagels with a modern twist, has been a leader of Steingold’s in North Center. You can get a pound of pastrami or lox, a cup of matzoh ball soup, or other items at Steingold’s, but the sandwiches—some classic, others unusual—are all made by hand from top-quality ingredients and designed to be memorable—are what keep customers coming back.

Chicago Bagel Authority – One of the Best Bagels in Chicago

Chicago Bagel Authority is a well-recognized bagel shop in the heart of Chicago. Steamed bagel sandwiches are available in a variety of flavors, including breakfast, vegetarian, and meatball alternatives. The Ohio-loving, toaster-shunning Chicago Bagel Authority steams each bagel it serves. Their massive bagel sandwiches are topped with a variety of meats, cheeses, eggs, and other ingredients. With premium meats, cheeses, and freshly chopped vegetables heaped in warm, luscious, melted delight, all of their sandwiches are served steamed the CBA way. 

The Chicago Bagel Authority is one of the best bagel shops in Chicago and has earned a name for its melty, steamed sandwiches, it offers its eponymous baked goods in a variety of ways, including a chewy, gooey bagel grilled cheese, the Cookie Monster, a chocolate chip cookie with cream cheese and cinnamon sugar atop a blueberry bagel, and The Swanson Sandwich of Greatness, a heart attack in the making with roast beef, ham, sausage, bacon, scrambled eggs, hardboiled and American and smoked cheddar cheese on an onion bagel. The Chicago Bagel Authority offers catering, takeout, and delivery services. Within Chicago, Chicago Bagel has two locations.

The Bagelers Coffeehouse

The Bagelers is one of Chicago’s best bagel shops. A team of husband and wife started it as a wholesale bakery just over five years ago now runs the store. The Bagelers has been honing its house-made spreads and Chicago-style bagels ever since. They hand-roll each croissant and boil their bagels to give them that distinctive chewing skin. The Bagelers sells Chicago-Style Kettle Boiled Bagels, house-made cream cheeses, spreads, different croissants, muffins, and scones, as well as a variety of delectable coffee beverages. One must try their farmer sandwich, a classic bagel sandwich made with freshly chopped oven-roasted turkey breast, muenster cheese, fresh lettuce, tomato slices, red onion, and their house-made chipotle mayo. No doubt they are considered to be among best bagels in Chicago.

Corey’s NYC Bagel Deli

Corey’s NYC Bagel Deli has been in the market for over 20 years and delivering delicious Chicago bagels to customers. It is a small, take-out bagel shop in the New York style that serves pizza, enormous sandwiches, and breakfast. The team sells more than 1,000 bagels every day at three metropolitan locations near Chicago. Corey’s NYC Bagel Deli is honoured to have been mentioned on The Profit on CNBC. Client meetings, Bar/Bat Mitzvahs, corporate gatherings, and graduations can all use their catering service. They sell freshly baked bagels made with high-quality ingredients. Customers at Corey’s NYC Bagel Deli have indoor seating and takeout options.